Best Loyalty Software for Small Restaurants: 2026 Costs

For most single-location restaurants, the best loyalty software is the one already attached to where your regulars pay. On Square POS, that's Square's loyalty program, included in Square Plus at $49/month per location. If repeat business is mostly online orders, Menuline includes loyalty on its $29/month Starter plan. For a plain digital punch card on any POS, Loopy Loyalty starts at $25/month.

Everything else on the market is either tied to a POS you'd have to buy (Toast, SpotOn) or priced for chains (Thanx, SumUp Connect). The table below has the real monthly numbers.

Disclosure: Menuline publishes this article and sells loyalty as part of its restaurant platform, so we compete with several tools here. We've ranked by fit for a small independent, said where others beat us, and labeled anything we couldn't confirm on the vendor's own page. If you want the design side (points vs punch cards, how generous to be), read our guide to restaurant loyalty programs. This page is about which software to buy.

What does restaurant loyalty software cost?

Software Monthly price Works with Rewards in-store sales? Contract
Square Loyalty (in Square Plus) $49 per location Square POS only Yes None
Menuline $29 Starter / $99 Growth Its own website and ordering No, online orders only Month-to-month
Loopy Loyalty $25 (1 location) / $69 / $95 Any POS (staff stamp a wallet card) Yes Monthly or annual
Toast Loyalty Not published; $50–$75 reported Toast POS only Yes Per your Toast agreement
SpotOn Loyalty $65 on top of SpotOn POS SpotOn POS only Yes Per your SpotOn agreement
UpMenu loyalty add-on $19 per location + ordering from $49 Its own ordering Online orders Cancel anytime
Menufy $149 (12-month) / $179 Its own ordering Online orders 12 months or monthly
Owner.com $249 + 5% per order, or $499 Its own ordering Online orders Month-to-month
SumUp Connect (formerly Fivestars) $269 / $349 Standalone or SumUp POS Yes Ask
Thanx Not published; $500+ reported 60+ POS and tech integrations Yes Ask

Prices per each vendor's published pricing page as of October 2026, except where marked "reported." Confirm with the vendor before you sign.

What does a small independent restaurant actually need from loyalty software?

Most loyalty software is built for chains with marketing teams. A one-location owner needs six things, and almost nothing else:

  1. It works where your regulars buy. A counter-service coffee shop needs in-store rewards. A takeout pizzeria doing half its sales online needs rewards on online orders. Pick software that covers the channel where repeat visits happen.
  2. No app download for guests. A phone number at the register, a wallet pass, or the account they already use to order online. Asking guests to install your app before their first reward loses most of them.
  3. A rule you can say in one sentence. "Every dollar earns a point, 100 points is a free entrée." If staff can't explain it during a rush, it won't run.
  4. Automatic reminders. The "you're one visit from a free burrito" message is where the behavior change happens. Software that can't send it by email or text is a punch card with extra steps.
  5. You can export the list. Your regulars' names and emails should leave with you if you switch.
  6. Month-to-month, under about $100. At one location, there's no reason to sign an annual contract for loyalty alone.

Notice what isn't on the list: tiers, gamification, AI segmentation. Those earn their keep at 20 locations, not at one.

Which loyalty software is best for a small restaurant?

Ranked by fit for a single-location independent spending under $100 a month on loyalty.

1. Square Loyalty: best if you already use Square POS

Per Square's pricing page, the loyalty program is part of Square Plus ($49/month per location) and Premium ($149), not Square Free. Plus also includes unlimited email campaigns and 500 texts a month, then 3¢ each, and lowers online card processing from 3.3% + 30¢ to 2.9% + 30¢. Square says guests can type in a phone number at checkout to earn points, redeem "in-store or online," and add a loyalty pass to Apple Wallet.

The catch: it only works with Square POS. And older guides quoting a $45/month standalone Square Loyalty price are out of date; Square's current pages bundle it into Plus.

2. Menuline: best if repeat business is online

Menuline includes loyalty and rewards on Starter ($29/month), alongside a restaurant website and commission-free online ordering. Diners earn points automatically when they order on your site or app and redeem them at checkout. Growth ($99/month) adds a branded iOS and Android app and AI-powered email marketing, including loyalty reminders. Both plans are $1/month for the first 3 months, month-to-month.

Honest limits: Menuline isn't a POS, so it can't reward walk-in counter sales. Ordering is pickup only today, with delivery by Uber drivers coming soon. Reminders are email only, no SMS. And diners pay a 5% platform fee at checkout.

3. Loopy Loyalty: best cheap punch card for any POS

Per Loopy Loyalty's pricing page, Starter is $25/month (or $250/year) for one location and one card design with unlimited customers; Growth is $69 for three locations and Ultimate $95 for ten. Guests save a stamp card to Apple or Google Wallet, and staff stamp it by scanning. There's a 15-day free trial with no card required, and you can cancel anytime, though Loopy doesn't refund partial periods.

It's the simplest honest option if you run Clover, Toast, or cash and just want digital punch cards. It won't connect rewards to what was ordered.

4. Toast Loyalty and SpotOn Loyalty: only if you're on that POS

Toast doesn't print a loyalty price on its public pages; its sales team quotes it as an add-on. A June 2026 review by Restaurantify reports roughly $50 to $75 a month. It requires Toast POS. If you're a Toast customer, check your contract for add-ons before adding another; our Toast FTC lawsuit explainer covers what to look for.

SpotOn lists Loyalty at $65/month added to a SpotOn POS subscription, per its loyalty page. It isn't sold without SpotOn POS.

Both are reasonable when you already own the POS. Neither is a reason to switch POS.

5. Bundled with online ordering: UpMenu, Menufy, Owner.com

  • UpMenu sells loyalty as a $19/month per location add-on to its ordering plans, which start at $49/month for 75 orders, per its pricing page.
  • Menufy includes a loyalty program and coupons, plus automated email and text marketing, for $149/month on a 12-month agreement or $179 month-to-month, per its pricing page.
  • Owner.com includes loyalty, email and SMS on both plans: $249/month + 5% per order or $499/month, per its pricing page. Guests pay a 5% order support fee, the same as Menuline's 5% diner fee, so that part is a wash.

6. Built for chains: SumUp Connect, Thanx, LoyaltyPass

  • SumUp Connect is what Fivestars became: fivestars.com now redirects to SumUp's loyalty page. Per SumUp's pricing page, Connect Plus is $269/month and Connect Pro $349, or $199 and $289 bundled with SumUp's POS.
  • Thanx doesn't publish pricing. Its site targets multi-location brands and cites 60+ POS and technology integrations. Third-party reviews, including one by Loop (a competitor), report entry pricing of $500 to $1,000+ a month.
  • LoyaltyPass now prices custom wallet-card programs from $9,500 as a one-time build, per its website. Older posts on its own blog mention a $99 monthly plan, so confirm which applies.

Free to try: Loop

Per Loop's pricing page, its Free plan covers up to 20 members, Grow is $29/month for 100 members, and Community $79 for 250. That's fine for testing the idea. A busy restaurant outgrows 250 members quickly.

How many extra orders does loyalty software need to pay for itself?

Here's a quick way to compare prices honestly. Each extra order covers its ticket minus food cost. At a $30 average ticket and 30% food cost, an order leaves $21 toward the software.

Extra $30 orders needed each month to cover loyalty software at 30% food cost: Loopy $25 needs 2, Menuline $29 needs 2, Square Plus $49 needs 3, SpotOn $65 needs 4, SumUp Connect Plus $269 needs 13, Thanx at a reported $500 needs 24

Software Monthly price Extra orders a month to break even
Loopy Loyalty Starter $25 2
Menuline Starter $29 2
Square Plus $49 3
SpotOn Loyalty $65 (plus POS) 4
SumUp Connect Plus $269 13
Thanx (reported) $500 24

That's a floor, not a forecast. It ignores labor and the rewards you give away. Rewards are cheaper than they look, though: a "$10 free entrée after $100 spent" reward costs you its food cost, about $3 at 30%, which is roughly 3% of the spend that earned it.

The point of the math: at $25 to $49 a month, loyalty software pays for itself if it brings back a couple of regulars one extra time. At $269 to $500, it needs a real marketing operation behind it.

When is a bigger loyalty platform worth it?

Give Thanx, SumUp Connect or Toast's marketing bundle a serious look if:

  • You run several locations and want one program and one guest list across all of them.
  • You have someone whose job is marketing. Segmentation and campaign tools pay off when someone uses them weekly.
  • You need deep POS data, such as rewarding specific items or dayparts, tied to a POS you already run.

For one location, those features mostly sit unused.

How do you set up loyalty without wasting a month?

  1. Start with your POS or ordering system. If it includes loyalty, turn that on first. It's the cheapest option and staff already know the screen.
  2. Write the one-sentence rule and print it at the register and on your ordering page.
  3. Make the first reward reachable within 3 to 5 visits, so new members feel progress.
  4. Turn on reminders, by email at minimum. Our email and SMS marketing guide covers what to send and how often.
  5. Check enrollment after 30 days. If almost nobody joined, the problem is the ask at checkout, not the software.

Loyalty works best when people can find and order from you directly in the first place; the free Menuline AI grader shows how your website and Google profile score on that.

The bottom line

For a small restaurant, loyalty software should cost $25 to $49 a month and live where your regulars already pay. On Square, use Square's program in Square Plus ($49/month per location). For online-heavy takeout, Menuline includes loyalty on its $29 Starter plan (online orders only; diners pay a 5% platform fee). On any other POS, Loopy Loyalty at $25 is the simple digital punch card. Toast and SpotOn loyalty make sense only if you already run their POS. Thanx, SumUp Connect and custom builds are priced for multi-location brands. Whatever you pick, it needs only about 2 to 3 extra orders a month to pay for itself at the low end, so the real test is whether guests ever hear about it.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best loyalty program software for a small restaurant?

It depends on where your regulars buy. On Square POS, Square's loyalty program comes with Square Plus at $49 a month per location. If most repeat orders are online, Menuline includes loyalty on its $29 Starter plan (diners pay a 5% platform fee). For a simple digital punch card on any POS, Loopy Loyalty starts at $25 a month. Prices per each vendor's published pricing as of 2026.

How much does restaurant loyalty software cost per month?

From $0 to over $500. Per published pricing as of 2026: Loop is free up to 20 members, Loopy Loyalty $25, Square Plus $49 per location, SpotOn Loyalty $65 on top of SpotOn POS, and SumUp Connect $269 or $349. Toast and Thanx don't publish loyalty prices; third-party reports put Toast Loyalty around $50 to $75 and Thanx at $500 or more.

Does Square Loyalty still cost $45 a month?

Not on Square's current plan pages. As of October 2026, Square lists its loyalty program, email marketing and text marketing as features of Square Plus ($49 a month per location) and Square Premium ($149), not Square Free. Older guides quoting a $45 standalone price are out of date.

Is Fivestars still available for restaurants?

Fivestars.com now redirects to SumUp's loyalty page. SumUp, which acquired Fivestars in 2021, sells the product as SumUp Connect: $269 a month for Connect Plus or $349 for Connect Pro, or $199 and $289 bundled with its POS, per SumUp's pricing page as of 2026.

How many extra orders does a loyalty program need to pay for itself?

Divide the monthly price by what an order leaves after food cost. At a $30 ticket and 30% food cost, each order covers $21, so a $49 program needs about 3 extra orders a month and a $269 program needs about 13. That ignores labor and the cost of rewards, so treat it as a floor.

Keep reading